D'Andrea's North - Gansevoort, New York

That Chubby Dude

Well I can say now with absolute certainty I’ve tried the worst pizza I’ve ever had before.

I asked for a cheese slice, I don’t know if this is their normal cheese or the guy messed up and gave me a white slice, but there was next to no sauce on the slice.

Let’s talk about the crust, the taste and consistency was somewhere between a biscuit and a saltine cracker. Just absolutely bland with no taste, it’s what I imagine Hardtack tastes like (look it up).

Come here if you want to see what the bottom of the pizza spectrum is.

Eleanor Williams

Last week our pizza & other sides were delicious so, we tried it again. This time the bottom of the pizza was burnt but the crust under the cheese was very doughy. The fried mushrooms were good but a little overdone & you only get 9 small pieces for $9.99. The boneless wings were good but hot for what was supposed to be mild. We're on the fence if we'll try it again?

Joe Brewer

In my 4 years of working at a wood fired pizza place as a head chef I have never, ever heard of a pizza that is literally white underneath and doughy in the middle be called a “cooked” pizza. When I called back about this undercooked pizza the man on the phone replied with bring it in so I did. When I brought it in they tore the pizza up which once again I have never seen before in my life. Fingers all over the whole pizza almost every slice was examined and after he ripped it up he threw it onto the box and says “looks cooked to me”. I payed over $50 for these two pizzas and kids were eating them after the kids ate the pepperoni pieces. Then when we went to eat our pizza and found it was raw. All they gave back was slices of pizza that were sitting out on the display and only one pizza worth. We did not get a refund, no apology, just one pizza worth of three different types of pizza. The garlic knots were burnt and had no garlic at all. Do not order pizza here.

Sharron Myers

The only day worth ordering from here is their 1/2 off large pie day on Tuesdays as their pizzas are wildly overpriced, inconsistent and moderate at best. Our kids enjoy the white broccoli but sometimes the pizzas are under cooked and sometimes they are burnt. Considering there are two similar italian takeout competitors very close nearby in Wilton, I would think D'andreas would be more concerned with having the same consistency as their original location. The delivery drivers are always pleasnt and we tip them well, but I will no longer be giving my patronage to a business where the owner's daughter who runs the joint has terrible professional boundaries. Multiple times she has shared information with other people about us and our orders... Why on Earth anyone would jeopardize their business by running their mouth is beyond me. We were consistent customers every Tuesday for the past 7 months, and my grandparents always got their pizza on Saturdays from this location for the last couple of years! They will also never be returning. It's sad that Tori has cost business for the company and her staff due to her personal issues; especially when we only live 1 mile away and always tipped the drivers $5 every time, so now she is taking money out of their pockets. If you are looking for Italian take out/pizza, order from Pizzatime right around the corner, you won't find $8 fries their like this place.

Zachary Fitzgerald

Pizza was old and tasteless. The place is a far cry from its counterpart. Should have went to stewarts and grabbed a couple of slices at least they would have been fresh.

F Scott

Gave me food poisoning. Spent a day in the ER and contacted the CDC as directed by the physician.

I had a salad, it tasted a bit soapy. Maybe even floral/sweet.

Judging by the other reviews on here, I probably should have looked first.

Can't recommend at all and I kinda hope the CDC shuts them down or at least conducts an investigation...

Probably looking at over $1,000 in medical expenses bc of this place.

Allan Lounsbury

Wow. My wife and l just had subs. Great food. He ordered a meatball parm yummy. I order a grilled chicken sandwich. We are both very full. The female driver was Extremely nice and very friendly. Food was delivered hot and fresh. I will always Recommend this place.

B Tyler

Definitely the worst pizza I’ve had since I’ve moved up here. Virtually no sauce, just undercooked greasy dough underneath melted cheese. Mentioned free delivery on the app so I gave it shot, wish I would’ve paid the delivery fee for another pizza place.